Occasional musings too long to fit in my facebook status updates

Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Thursday, August 11, 2011

Super Committee

What are the odds of a "grand bargain" by the so-called "super committee" this fall?  Below is a table of the 12 members and how their lifetime voting records compare to other members of their respective legislative bodies and caucuses.

One could use any number of rankings services or dissect their voting records in various ways and come up with quite different rankings -- as such, this should be interpreted as a first attempt to gain a rough idea of how liberal or conservative the various members are rather than any sort of authoritative study.

That said, the results are somewhat distressing to those hoping for a productive session.  8 of the 12 members are more liberal/conservative than the median member of their caucus and 9 of 12 have voted with their party more than 90% of the time.  Democrat Max Baucus is slightly more conservative than the median Senator and Fred Upton is slightly more liberal than the median Representative, though Rob Portman has also been mentioned as somebody potentially willing to compromise in news reports despite his conservative voting record.

In the Senate it's plain to see that Harry Reid nominated far more moderate members than did Mitch McConnell (by both relative ranks within their party and absolute voting numbers) -- indeed, the most moderate Republican is more conservative than the least moderate Democrat is liberal.  In the House, the story is more muddled.  Relative to their respective caucuses the Republicans are more moderate, but based on their absolute voting records the Democrats could be seen as slightly more moderate.

On average, the Democrats on the committee are more liberal than 49% of their caucus and have voted with their party 89.3% of the time while the Republicans on the committee are more conservative than 63% of their caucus and have voted with their party 95% of the time.  Based on these metrics, the Democrats could be described as more moderate than are the Republicans.

But the political leanings of the average member from each party may be less important than the potential swing votes.  Any chance of the committee's recommendation receiving 7 votes may hinge on Republicans convincing Max Baucus to go along with their plan or Democrats convincing Fred Upton to go along with theirs.  It seems somewhat less likely that the seven most moderate members across party lines would reach an agreement given that only 4 have more moderate voting records than the median member of their party.

It's too early to give up hope entirely, but the voting records of the members of the committee appear to allow little chance of a productive and civil session.  The better idea would have been to allow the four leaders to appoint one or more members from the opposite party to the committee.



Senate DemocratsSenate Republicans
Liberal Rank% Voting with PartyParty PercentileConservative Rank% Voting with PartyParty Percentile
Max Baucus52nd75.49%2%Jon Kyl*16th96.20%66%
Patty Murray*26th91.11%51%Rob Portman12th96.36%74%
John Kerry24th91.50%55%Pat Toomey2nd98.15%96%
House DemocratsHouse Republicans
Liberal Rank% Voting with PartyParty PercentileConservative Rank% Voting with PartyParty Percentile
James Clyburn121st89.48%37%Fred Upton218th84.70%9%
Chris Van Hollen60th93.45%69%Dave Camp150th97.05%37%
Xavier Becerra41st94.49%79%Jeb Hensarling13th97.80%95%



*co-chairs

liberal/conservative rank: 1st corresponds to most liberal/conservative member of that body, the Senate has 53 Democrats (including two Independents) and 47 Republicans while the House has 240 Republicans and 193 Democrats

% Voting with Party: The percentage of the member's vote that have aligned with the party position during their career.

Party Percentile: The percentage of their respective caucus who the member is more liberal (in the case of Democrats) or conservative (in the case of Republicans) than: a higher number represents a less moderate politician.

Monday, March 29, 2010

Has Opinion on Health Care Shifted?

For months leading up to the passage of health care, the pollster.com average found a net plurality of around 5-12 percentage points disapproved of the plan.  The first poll taken after passage, however, found the public in favor of the plan by a 49-40 margin.  Was that just an outlier, or has opinion actually shifted?

There have been five polls polls taken after passage of the bill.  Here's how they stack up:



Favor Oppose Net
WaPo 46 50 -4
CBS 42 46 -4
Quinnipiac 40 49 -9
USA Today-Gallup 49 40 9
YouGov 50 50 0
average 45.4 47 -1.6

Across these five polls, a plurality still disapprove of health care -- but only a very slight one.  Let's compare them to the last five polls released before passage:



Favor Oppose Net
Bloomberg 38 50 -12
CNN 39 59 -20
CBS 37 48 -11
Quinnipiac 36 54 -18
Rasmussen 41 54 -13
average 38.2 53 -14.8

The last five polls were among the most negative of the past year.  Whether this is due to the build-up before passage or simply the five that happened to be last, I can't quite say.  Comparing these 10, we see a 13 point swing in net approval of the health care bill.  But this might not be the right comparison groups.  Given the different questions and samples of the polls, it might be better to compare polls taken by the same organization before and after.  There have been three of these:



After
Before

Favor Oppose Net Favor Oppose Net
CBS 42 46 -4 37 48 -11
Quinnipiac 40 49 -9 36 54 -18
YouGov 50 50 0 48 53 -5
average 44 48.33 -4.33 40.33 51.67 -11.33

Looking at only these three, we find a 7 point swing in net approval -- and we still see a small plurality (though not majority) opposed to the bill.

The trend could be just a blip, could be based on a few faulty polls, or could be a genuine shift in how Americans view the health care bill (or at least how they report they feel).  If the first two are true, new polls will pretty quickly bear this out.  But there are two fairly good reasons to believe that the last one is, in fact, happening:

1.) The initial results were misleading.  Take the these results from a Bloomberg poll taken right before the vote in which 38% favored the bill and 50% were opposed

Health care is so complicated it is hard for the average American to understand the proposals that are currently being discussed
75% Agree, 23% Disagree

The cost of doing nothing on health care will be greater than the cost of the proposed plan to overhaul it
51% Agree, 40% Disagree

The health care system is fine the way it is
20% Agree, 79% Disagree

In short, people don't know much about the health care bill but they want to do something to fix the broken health care system.

2.) As 538 points out, a small but meaningful number of people opposed the bill b/c it wasn't liberal enough.  The approval numbers among Independents and Republicans in the new USA Today/Gallup poll is roughly similar to other previous polls, but the approval numbers among Democrats are much higher.

In the last poll before the bill passed (and outlier in terms of negativity toward the bill), conducted by CNN, 59% reported that they were opposed to the bill -- but 13% reported opposing the bill b/c it wasn't liberal enough.  In other words, 52% of the population either favored the bill or thought it wasn't liberal enough while 43% opposed the bill b/c it was too liberal.

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Does Gun Control Work?

I always assumed that states with stricter gun control also had more gun deaths per capita, for two reasons: 1.) I figured more rural areas usually had less crime and since more rural states are more conservative, that they'd also have laxer gun control laws, and 2.) states with more gun deaths would have more motivation to pass stricter gun control laws.   If my assumption were true, it would be easy for anybody to argue that states with fewer gun regulations also have fewer gun deaths.  Apparently I was wrong.

Over at 538 today, Tom Schaller mentioned that, outside of DC, "the ten states with the lowest per-capital gun death rates voted for Obama."  He referenced this chart of firearm deaths per 100,000 residents by state.  If we cross-reference these data with the percent that voted for Obama in each state (here), we get a rather striking picture.



DC is a notable outlier -- it's no surprise that there are more gun deaths there than anywhere else.  But if we look at only the 50 states, the correlation between gun deaths and the percent who voted for Obama is a strikingly high -.63, (p<.001).  If we graph only the 50 states, it's readily apparent that the relationship is quite strong.



The data are almost too perfect -- there don't even appear to be any real outliers.  Indeed, if we look at the original chart in a new way -- color coded by the political leanings of the state -- it again appears almost too perfect.  In the chart below, the state is blue if it voted for both Kerry and Obama, purple if it voted for Bush and Obama, and red if it voted for Bush and McCain in '04 and '08.


24 of the top 25 states voted for Bush in 2004, and and 20 of the 25 bottom states voted for Obama in 2008.  If we break down the average gun deaths by type of state, we get:

red: 13.83
purple: 12.1
blue: 7.47

In other words, blue states have almost half the rate of gun deaths as do red states.  If we regress gun deaths on the percentage voting for Obama, we find out that a 10 percentage point gain in Obama voting is associated with a decrease of 2.9 gun deaths per 100,000 people, or .67 standard deviations (r squared = .402).

So, what does this mean?  Well, I think it's fair to assume that the percentage of people in a state who voted for Obama is fairly reasonable proxy for how liberal a state is -- which should also be a fairly reasonable proxy for how strict a state's gun control laws are.  So it seems almost certain that, controlling for nothing else, states with stricter gun control laws tend to have fewer gun deaths per capita.  Which means that gun control works . . . right?  Not really.  Like I said, this controls for nothing else.  One potentially mediating variable is gun ownership.  I have to believe the rates of gun ownership are fairly strongly correlated with how conservative a state is -- hence states with more guns were less likely to vote for Kerry or Obama.  Though even if that's true, I see two problems with arguing that it invalidates these statistics:

1.) One of the arguments against gun control is that people can -- and do -- safely own guns.  And that guns don't kill people -- people kill people.  But if states with higher rates of gun ownership also have higher rates of gun deaths that calls that assumption into question.

2.) One of the goals of gun control is to reduce both the number of people who own guns and the number of guns each person owns.  The narrative I've heard in the media is that it's not very successful at doing this -- which I find quite plausible -- but it's still possible that gun control reduces gun ownership a little bit, which would mean that gun ownership would be associated both with how much people feel they need guns and rules regarding gun ownership.

One of the commenters on 538 argues that gun deaths is a misleading statistic, and that we should use homicides involving guns instead.  But I disagree.  Gun control doesn't aim only to prevent murders with guns, it also aims to prevent gun accidents (e.g. by requiring child-proof safety locks).  It's certainly worth looking at both, but I'd put the latter above the former in terms of importance.


I find it most interesting that despite having more urban areas (which usually have higher rates of crime), more liberal states have fewer gun deaths.  Indeed, if we were going to conduct a rigorous investigation of whether gun control works or not, we'd certainly have to factor in urbanicity, poverty, non-gun crime rates, gun ownership rates, and a number of other variables.  We'd also want to know if there were any other effects of the gun control policy beside that on gun deaths (e.g. were more people killed with knives, or were there more home invasions b/c robbers knew homeowners were less likely to have guns?)

Anyway, here are the possible conclusions we can draw from these data (and given the limited scope we can't be sure that any one of these conclusions is better than the rest):

1.) The data are faulty -- real life isn't usually that neat and clean, and the list could have been doctored or simply made up

2.) Gun control works -- states that have stricter gun control laws also tend to have fewer gun deaths despite being more urban

3.) Gun control is irrelevant, demographic factors matter a lot more

4.) Gun ownership is dangerous, regardless of whether one is in an urban or rural location


5.) Nothing.  Far more research would be needed to draw any conclusions.

I'll stick with number 5 until I see more evidence.

About Me

Buffalo, New York, United States